torstai 17. syyskuuta 2015

How to argue terribly

  1. Appeal to bandwagon (Miska and Miiko)
    • Bad arguments:
      • You should buy an iPhone because everyone else has one.
      • You should smoke because all the cool kids do it.
      • You shouldn’t wear a helmet because other people don’t.
    • Good arguments:
      • You should go to school because everyone else does.
      • You should eat because everyone alive eats.
      • You should brush your teeth because everyone with good oral hygiene does it.
  2. Appeal to irrelevant authority (Julia and Aino)
    • Bad arguments:
      • People in medieval times said that they had witnessed witchcraft so it has to be true.
      • Because the bible says world was created by God it has to be true.
      • Santa Claus is real because everyone knows him.
    • Good arguments:
      • We know that the earth is round because we’ve seen it from space.
      • Finland is a bilingual country because it was once part of Sweden.
      • 9/11 really happened because a lot of people were there to witness it.
3. No true Scotsman (Luka, Nikolas, Otso)
    • Bad arguments:
      • No true fan of metal listens electronic music. 
      • No true patriot has ever committed a crime.
      • Only true believers can get to heaven.  
    • Good arguments:
      • A true weapon causes destruction.
      • A true country is recognised by other countries.  
      • A true doctor has been taught how to help people.
     4. Hasty generalization (Atte and Kasper

    • Bad arguments:
      • VR is always late because 2 people said so.
      • School chairs are comfortable because we like them.
      • All politicians are corrupted because one news article said so.
    • Good arguments:
      • Drugs are bad for you because they make you go crazy.
      • Exercises are good for you because they help to learn.
      • Sleeping is good for you because it scientifically proven to be helpful organize new things you have learned.
4. Hasty generalization (Jesse and Gibriil)


    • Bad arguments:
      • My teacher is annoying. Therefore, all teachers are annoying.
      • I have seen only fat Americans. Therefore all Americans are fat.
      • My Finnish friend drinks a lot of coffee. Therefore all Finns drink coffee.
    • Good arguments:
      • Finland consumes the most coffee in the world per capita, therefore we can assume that most Finns drink coffee.
      • Estonia is the biggest alcohol consumer in the world, therefore we can assume Estonians drink quite much alcohol.
      • In Iceland there are the most cannabis smokers per capita. Therefore we can assume that a lot of cannabis is consumed in Iceland.


      5. Appeal to Ignorance (Eric and Jere)
    • Bad Arguments:
      • Look at that commercial, it has an awesome looking burger in it. It must be like that in the restaurants.
      • There is an object in the sky! It must be an UFO.
      • The ratings said that movie is really good. It must be, because of the rating.
    • Good Arguments:
      • I can run very fast. I have tested it.
      • There is a garbage collector on the streets. He must be environmentally aware.
      • The outside is very foggy. It must be moist.
5. Appeal to Ignorance (Julia, Sonata and Camilla)
    • Bad arguments
      • Have you ever seen a McDonald’s be built? Neither have we - so it’s obviously…

      • Why is Donald Trump winning the election in the USA this year? Nobody is actually voting for him, so it must be…

      • Why is Johanna Tukiainen famous? Nobody knows, so of course the answer is...


    • Good arguments
      • Why is Justin Bieber so famous? The world is full of weird people called…

      • Why on Earth is Kim Kardashian famous? Well it’s because of her…
6. Argument from Consequences (Egor and Ahmed)


    • Bad arguments: 
      • If we stop eating meat animals will stop dying.
      • If we wouldn’t have laws life would be easy.
      • If we would stop using renewable energy we would make our planet cleaner.
    • Good arguments:
      • If we wouldn’t go to school we would be uneducated. 
      • If we wouldn’t have jobs people would steal.
      • If we wouldn’t have internet we couldn’t contact people from another side of the planet.



7. Not a cause for a cause (Asmaa and Seyda)


    • Bad arguments:
      • I  couldn’t come to school, because my socks  colour didn’t match.
      • I didn’t study for exams, because I didn’t have time.
      • Why didn’t you answer to my calls? I was too lazy to answer to the phone
    • Good arguments:
      • I was sick, therefore I couldn’t come to school.
      • I want a good job, therefore I study.
      • I didn’t go to shop, because I couldn’t find my wallet.